PCB Design Perfection Starts in the CAD Library – Part 19

PCB Breakaway Panels

 As PCB part placements get denser, it’s necessary to add breakaway panels that add additional board material (edge rails) to accommodate the assembly process. Two parallel edges are required for a PCB to be processed in the SMT line. This is to prevent skewing through the conveyor system. Also, all odd shaped PCB’s must have edge rails incorporated to meet this requirement. Custom reflow fixtures will be made, at an additional cost to you, if this requirement is not met. The breakaway tabs remain intact all the way through the assembly process and are removed at the final stage.

V-Grove Score and Tab Routing are two common methods used for creating breakaway tabs. Tab Routing uses perforated breakaway tabs (sometimes referred to as “Mouse Bites”). The breakaway tab closest to the PCB corner should be located between 10 mm and 12 mm from the edge to reduce sagging during reflow or wave soldering. It is also preferred to have at least one tab per side. If the PCB placement is too dense for a Tooling Hole, then it should be placed on the breakaway tab. See Figure 1 for the optimized breakaway tab solution.

Note: all dimensions in this paper are in millimeter units.

Figure 1 - Example of Breakaway Panel

 One important aspect is to have a clean edge after the breakaway tab is removed. Slight inset of perforation is preferred because it provides an edge which requires little to no additional labor to clean up. Figure 2 illustrates the perforation location preferences.

Figure 2 - Breakaway Perforation Locations

 The spacing between breakaway tabs can range from 60 mm to 90 mm, but I recommend 77 mm from center to center as shown in Figure 3. Try not to exceed 100 mm between tabs and try to evenly space them apart.

Figure 3 - Breakaway Tab Spacing

 The plane pull-back should be at least 1 mm from all slots and perforation holes. All trace routing needs to be over a plane for clean return path so keep all routing 1 mm from all slots and perforation holes. Keep components 2 mm – 3mm away from the routed slots. These rules help prevent components or trace damage during the de-paneling process. See Figure 4 to define the keep-out areas in the PCB layout.

Figure 4 - Plane & Component Spacing

 Tab routing is more precise than V-groove scoring and edge surfaces are smooth. The breakaway tab points require consideration for additional smoothing if necessary to comply with the fabrication drawing note regarding smooth edges. The dilled perforation provides a low stress break point on the tab and if the hole pattern is recessed within the printed board edge, secondary sanding or grinding can be avoided.

 It is not recommended to substitute perforation holes with a V-groove score as it does not provide a durable tab that will withstand handling. V-groove scoring can however be used in place of routing, but requires board edge grinding to smooth the surface. The V-groove feature is generally provided on both sides of the PCB and only in a straight line. A V-Groove depth that will provide a sturdy work-piece and still separate with light to moderate pressure after assembly is an important element in manufacturing. Many PCB fabrication shops recommend a V-grove depth that is 1/3 of the PCB thickness from both sides using Computer Numerical Control (CNC) equipment. The alignment or positional accuracy of the two grooves is critical for clean separation and minimizes post separation board edge smoothing. According to IPC-2222 Section 5.3.1, the alignment tolerance for the V-groove is ±80 µm. Figure 5 illustrates the 90° scoring option. It is important that all conductors be routed within a minimum distance of 1 mm from the top of the scoring edge to prevent damage during de-paneling. The inner layer planes should be pulled back 1 mm from the V-groove. The PCB designer should collaborate with the PCB fabrication shop on the V-groove angle option that they use.

Figure 5 - 90 Degree V-Groove Scoring

 Figure 6 illustrates the 30° scoring option and uses the same rules.

Figure 6 - 30 Degree V-Groove Scoring

 It is important to note that the 1/3 depth rule only applies to “Breakaway Panels”. V-Groove scoring inner web material can range from 0.15 mm to 0.4 mm for panel separation depending on the length of the score. If the score length is less than 25 mm, it can have a web thickness of 0.15 mm and scores that are 100 mm long can have a web thickness of 0.25 mm and scores that are longer than 100 mm can have a web thickness of 0.4 mm. These values are just guidelines and should be discussed with your assembly shop to confirm the web thickness for your printed circuit board design.

 

Post Author

Posted June 23rd, 2011, by

Post Tags

, ,

Post Comments

6 Comments

About Tom Hausherr's Blog

New component package technology and CAD library standards. Tom Hausherr's Blog

@MentorPCB tweets

  • What makes PCB Library creation and maintenance a whole lot easier? Danit's blog with help you find out: http://t.co/iVgKRGjJ4v
  • Only one more week until the European U2U Conference! Register here if you haven't already: http://t.co/0Vh0TqonjB
  • Mentor Graphics Announces Xpedition System Designer for Comprehensive Multi-board systems development. http://t.co/uBJe9PVYfp

Follow MentorPCB

Comments

6 comments on this post | ↓ Add Your Own

Commented on July 6, 2011 at 1:37 am
By Pete

How would you approach a board with a cutout? ie:
——————– ———————–
| |
—————–

Commented on July 7, 2011 at 4:50 am
By Fran Wheeler

Thank you Tom your blog and PCBDesign007 posts are so informative…being separated from the actual assembly processes as a service bureau all the input you can get is wonderful.

Commented on January 10, 2012 at 8:49 am
By Adam Geboff

Tom,

I am a young EE design engineer and have been doing schematic design and PCB layout for a few years and cane across a few of your articles regarding the “library of the future” and these “PCB Design Perfection Starts in the CAD Library.” I have had a question regarding PCB libraries since i began and have not been able to get a strait answer from anyone and believe you would be the definitive source!

If there are standard component dimensions, and standard pad dimension calculations, and standard naming convention, then why isn’t there just a standard library for the major EDA tools with all of the standard components? If the argument is the tools, then why not adopt a vector based library file format which can then be used across all EDA tools so then only 1 library would need to be developed for ALL tools?

I would GREATLY appreciate any resolution to this nagging question!

Thank you,

Adam Geboff
Senior Electrical Engineer

Commented on November 12, 2012 at 9:04 am
By EE Bookshelf: PCB Panelization « adafruit industries blog

[...] I’ve come across on the subject (and I’ve picked up a lot of books over the years): PCB Design Perfection Starts in the CAD Library Part 19:  PCB Breakaway Panels.  The information is SW neutral, and it gives you all the key measurements you need for your first [...]

[...] If you’re laying out boards and need to work on panels you can do MouseBites or Vscores to get your boards free of the panel. [...]

Commented on March 11, 2014 at 12:13 pm
By Michael Warner

On Table 2 – Referring to Vias. This does not follow IPC-2221B Land Pattern calculations. The formula states Pad = A + 2B+C, A 400umx150um will not fall into this chart.
How are you deriving this calculations. The drill is 0.15, the annular ring is 2*0.05, and the Fabrication Allowance is a min. of 0.200 (all in mm) so how are you getting a .400 pad size?

Add Your Comment